Christopher Wakeling and Nikolaus Pevsner.
Yale University Press. Hardback, £40.00. ISBN 9780300218350
Review by: Ruth Barbour
This volume is the latest publication in a series of architectural guides, the first of which was published in 1951.The local historian is helped by a number of standard reference books published as part of a series. The history of a settlement if it existed in Anglo-Saxon times will usually include in its first chapter a quote from the translation of the Domesday Book entry for its county. Charters and taxation records (Feet of Fines) when available are quoted for later medieval times again county by county. Hearth Tax returns have been published in a uniform series for many but not all counties. Perhaps only one series has volumes published for every English county in a unform, academic study mode. Sir Nikolaus Pevsner (1902-83), the early ninety fifties pioneered this series which bears his name. A pre-war refuge from Nazi Germany, in England, he held chairs of the History of Art firstly at Birbeck College (University of London) and then at Cambridge. Each volume was devoted to an individual county. Its best-known part is the gazetteer, arranged by individual settlements which contain detailed surveys of notable buildings, churches, public buildings, stately homes and more humble vernacular buildings. For larger settlements (towns and cities) ‘per-ambulation’s’ are included in which most of the houses on an individual street are described. The first series, that was completed in 1973, usually contained over one hundred black and white photo-graphs together with drawings in the text. Each volume also contained general chapters outlining the development within each county of its architecture, including names of architects and, interestingly, the geology of the area which of course influenced the building materials used. The period covered stretches from bronze age to the modern and the Romans receive specific attention.
A section, ‘Further Reading’ provided a critical bibliography academics helpful for researchers undertaking a literature search. And an extensive glossary defines the niche technical terms The original volumes were published by Penguin, Pevsner had enlisted the support of Sir Allen Lane, the founder of that press. Over the years, the series has required considerable financial support not least in funding the researchers who fully researched each country before the editors visited each site described. In addition, each volume has been presented to ahigh standard. Over the years, the publications have been supported by various trusts. Then in the 1990s, the series was bought by Yale University Press (one Open History 17042of the leading publishers of English academic history books). A very English series is now produced in America (and printed in China.) This year, the publication of the second Stafford-shire volume has received more than usual press attention. Why? Just as its first edition completed the first round of publications in 1974, this second edition completes the second round.
All counties now have at least a second edition published. Some such as those around London have progressed to a third or even a fourth completely revised edition. This Staf-fordshire volume now appropriately reproduces Pe-vsner’s reflection on the completion of the (first series) of the Buildings of England. Simon Bradley, the current general editor, in his introduction outlines the detailed work undertaken in its production and the large number of experts who contributed. He had sadly to note the untimely death of the second credited editor Dr Christopher Wakeling (1948-2023), an Honorary Fellow at Keele University for thirty years and a former chair of the Society of Architectural Historians of Great Britain, one of the many whose lives were ended prematurely by Covid. How does this second edition differ from its predecessor? It is much larger than its predecessor: 757 pages as against 378 pages. And the pages are bigger so there is much more text. The number of photographs (now in brilliant colour) have increased from 104 to 123. This is despite the area covered being smaller because of the 1974 boundary changes. The Black Country (including Dudley, Walsall and Wolverhampton, once an integral part of industrial Staffordshire, has been transferred to a new volume Birmingham and the Black Country as it has joined the city in the new Metropolitan County of the West Midlands. When I lived in the Black Country it felt avery different area from Birmingham in which I grew up. The large city was not a focal point of interest. Where I lived and worked Essington remains partly in South Staffordshire – the new estates are now part of Walsall, but the historic buildings, such as they were, remain in Staffordshire. When I lived there my focus was on Wolverhampton, I rarely went into Walsall.
This perhaps demonstrates the difficulty of categorising places by time and locality. Something that can cause difficulties for researchers looking for primary sources The further reading section highlights another change. It notes that it is a sign of the times that online resources have increased so that it can be said that they ‘are proliferating [so] that few publications will not be available electronically’. Often such facilities are held behind a pay wall. An example of this is JSTOR (essential for accessing online journals which is widely available via academic institution websites but may be difficult for independent scholars to access. Perhaps the delay in publishing Staffordshire in both rounds of editions may be related to its recent industrial past. In the latter half of the nineteenth century, coal emerged as the fuel for industrialisation. Into the twentieth century miners from both South Wales and the Mining districts of the Northeast moved into the coal mining districts of Staffordshire-especially the South Staffordshire and Cannock Chase coal mines and similar areas to the north of Stoke-on- Trent. Settlements such as Cannock grew dramatically, and the architecture was functional rather than aesthetic. Stafford, the county town, is situated in the middle of the county on the River Sow. The site was fortified by Æthelflaed, Lady of the Mercians, in 913 as she pushed the control of Wessex her father Alfred’s kingdom north to the Mersey. Two towns (Lichfield Tamworth) further south in the county were the heartland of the Anglo-Saxon kingdom of Mercia.
The judgement on the aesthetics of Stafford (population only 68,500 in 2011) is that (visually), next to Lichfield it is the most attractive major town [in the county]. Lichfield, too, was founded by the Anglo-Saxons and its history is dominated by the Cathedral and its connection with St Chad. It is not one of the largest English medieval cathedrals, but it has two features that single it out. ‘It has three spires – only Victorian Truro also has those – and it has ‘two pools to southward and eastward, ensuring a picturesque-ness of setting which none can emulate’. Over twenty pages are devoted to the description of the Cathedral. During the Civil War, the Parliamentarians whilst besieging it caused considerable damage to the structure. One link with its Anglo-Saxon past is seen on one of the colour plates: a stone angel carving in the present-day Chapter House. The Ca-thedral’s foundations go back to the Anglo-Saxons, in particular to, St Chad, the second Bishop ofLichfield.Elsewhere, the architecture seen in the larger towns is often of a more functional (industrial) nature.
Burton upon Trent is famous for brewing. The advent of the railways aided the trade and by the late nineteenth century, breweries covered 174 acres of land. Cheadle is another town that in the nineteenth-century ‘was dominated by industry, collieries, cop-per works and textile mills.’ Pugin wrote that St Giles(R.C.)…1841-6‘ is a perfect revival of an English parish church of the time of Edward I. He said so not to praise himself but to praise the 16th Earl of Shrewsbury, at whose expense the church was built. This church is one of Pugin’s masterpieces. The city of Stoke-on-Trent created in 1924 united six towns famous for the manufacture of pottery. Its centenary is being celebrated this year. Arnold Bennett, perhaps its most famous son, reduced the number of towns to five whilst still providing a realistic picture in his novels of late Victorian aspiring middle-class life in which the non-conformist chapels played a prominent role. My memories of six months working in Stoke are limited. In those days the life of a junior hospital doctor was restricted by 1:2 rotas and residence within the hospital. Serious lung diseases prevalent: many adults had worked in the mines or the pots. The hospitals of fifty years ago no longer exist. New roads now enable the motorist to tear through the heartland of the potteries. Time has moved on. And this is one of the rationales for this series – to provide at different points in time a comprehensive survey of the buildings within one administrative unit. This may be a county, or part of a city or in the case of Birmingham and the Black Country a new Metropolitan County. As readers may have gathered, I am a fan of this series. Increasingly, as well as browsing the gazetteers, I find it illuminating to read the historical survey chapters. It is intriguing to see how interpretation and indeed knowledge of sites, especially Roman ones has increased between editions.
Pevsner’s general dislike of industrial and Victorian buildings has been replaced a growing nostalgia for both these eras. I won’t be around to see it, but perhaps in another fifty years Brutalist buildings will be revered! This volume and the series are highly recommended

